Is Costco Gas Better Than BJ's? [A Comparative Analysis] - (2024)

Is Costco gas better than BJ’s? Many people are curious about which warehouse club offers the best fuel options.

While both Costco and BJ’s offer discounted gas prices, there are some differences in the quality and availability of their fuel.

In this article, we will explore the differences between Costco and BJ’s gas, including the quality and availability of their fuel, as well as any other factors that may impact your decision.

By the end of this article, you will have a better understanding of which warehouse club offers the best gas options for your needs.

Table of Contents

Is Costco Gas Better Than Bj’s?

To answer this question, one of the main factors to consider is the certification of the gas. Costco gas is certified as “Top Tier,” which means it exceeds the minimum standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

BJ’s, on the other hand, does not have this certification, but they do offer their own fuel stations and sell gas for several cents less per gallon than regular locations.

Another factor to consider is location, as BJ’s operates exclusively in the eastern half of the United States and has considerably fewer locations than Costco.

Is Costco gas cheaper than BJ’s?

Is Costco Gas Better Than BJ's? [A Comparative Analysis] - (1)

One of the biggest factors people consider when buying gas is the price. So, is Costco gas cheaper than BJ’s? The answer is, it depends.

According to a study by GasBuddy, Costco gas is on average 5-10 cents cheaper per gallon than BJ’s. However, this can vary depending on location and other factors.

It’s important to note that both Costco and BJ’s require a membership to buy gas. So, if you’re not already a member of either, you’ll need to factor in the cost of membership when comparing prices.

Is BJ’s gas as good as Costco’s?

It depends. Both Costco and BJ’s use Top Tier gasoline, which means it meets a higher standard of quality than regular gasoline.

Top Tier gasoline contains more detergents and additives that help keep your engine clean and running smoothly.

However, some people claim that Costco gas is better because it contains fewer additives, which can lead to better gas mileage and performance.

It’s worth noting that there isn’t much scientific evidence to support these claims, and the difference in performance is likely to be minimal.

Costco Gas vs. BJ’s Gas: Comparison

When it comes to buying gas, you want to make sure you’re getting the best quality and price for your money.

Two popular warehouse clubs, Costco and BJ’s, both offer gas at their fuel centers. But which one is better?

Let’s compare Costco gas and BJ’s gas.

1. Price Comparison

Price is a significant factor when it comes to buying gas. BJ’s gas prices tend to run around $0.10 below the national average.

On the other hand, Costco’s gas prices are usually a few cents above the national average. However, it’s essential to note that gas prices can vary depending on your location.

BJ’s also offers its members discounts on gas when they use their BJ’s Perks Plus® or BJ’s Perks Elite® credit cards. Members can save up to 10 cents per gallon.

Costco, on the other hand, doesn’t offer any credit card discounts. However, they do offer gas at a fixed markup of 15 cents per gallon over their cost.

This means that their gas prices are consistent across all locations and don’t fluctuate as much as BJ’s prices.

2. Quality Comparison

When it comes to gas quality, Costco has an advantage over BJ’s. Costco’s gas is certified as “Top Tier,” which means it’s higher quality than even the EPA requires.

Top Tier gas has a higher concentration of detergents that help keep your engine clean and running smoothly.

BJ’s gas, on the other hand, is not Top Tier certified. However, they do offer a gas quality guarantee. If you experience any problems with your car after using BJ’s gas, they will pay for any necessary repairs.

Another factor to consider is the type of gas each warehouse club offers.

Costco only sells Top Tier Gas, while BJ’s offers both regular and premium gas. If your car requires premium gas, BJ’s may be a better option for you.

Benefits of Costco Gas

If you’re looking for quality gas for your car, you might want to consider Costco. Here are some benefits of Costco gas that you might find appealing:

#1. Top-Quality Fuel

Costco gasoline is Top Tier certified, which means it contains a higher level of detergent additives that help keep your engine clean and running smoothly.

According to a study by AAA, Top Tier gasoline had 19 times fewer carbon deposits on injectors, intake valves, and in the combustion chamber than non-Top Tier gasoline.

This means that Costco gas can help improve your car’s performance and fuel efficiency.

#2. Fuel Additives

In addition to being Top Tier certified, Costco gasoline also contains additives that help protect your engine against wear and tear.

These additives can help extend the life of your engine and reduce the need for costly repairs down the road.

#3. Convenient Locations

Costco gas stations are located at or near Costco warehouses, which means you can fill up your tank while you’re doing your shopping.

This can be a time-saver for busy people who don’t want to make an extra trip to the gas station.

Benefits of BJ’s Gas

If you are wondering whether BJ’s Gas is a good option for you, there are several benefits that you should consider.

#1. Competitive Prices

BJ’s Gas offers competitive prices for their fuel. According to a recent study, BJ’s Gas prices are often lower than the prices at traditional gas stations.

This means that you can save money on every gallon of gas that you purchase.

#2. Membership Rewards

BJ’s Gas is part of the BJ’s Wholesale Club, which means that you can take advantage of membership rewards.

BJ’s Wholesale Club offers a variety of benefits to its members, including cashback rewards, discounts on merchandise, and access to exclusive deals.

By purchasing gas at BJ’s Gas, you can earn rewards that you can use to save money on other purchases.

#3. Convenient Locations

BJ’s Gas has convenient locations throughout the United States. Whether you are traveling on a long road trip or just need to fill up your tank, you can find a BJ’s Gas location that is close to you.

BJ’s Gas also offers a mobile app that you can use to find the nearest location, check gas prices, and more.

Which gas station has better quality fuel, Costco or BJ’s?

When it comes to choosing between Costco and BJ’s for fuel, one of the most important factors to consider is the quality of the fuel.

Both Costco and BJ’s offer gasoline that meets the Top Tier standard, which means that their fuel contains higher-quality detergents that can help keep your car’s engine clean and running smoothly.

Overall, when it comes to the quality of the fuel, both Costco and BJ’s offer Top Tier gasoline that meets the industry standard.

However, Costco’s use of its own Kirkland Signature brand and its reputation for low prices may make it a more attractive option for some drivers.

Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on your personal preferences and priorities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Lets look at some of the frequently asked questions

Are there any differences in the gas quality between Costco and BJ’s?

Both Costco and BJ’s sell high-quality gas that meets or exceeds industry standards. The gas sold at Costco and BJ’s is Top Tier, which means it contains a higher concentration of detergents that help keep your engine clean and running smoothly.

Is there any advantage to getting gas at Costco or BJ’s?

One advantage of getting gas at Costco or BJ’s is the price. Both retailers offer gas at lower prices than many other gas stations. Costco is known for having some of the lowest gas prices in the industry, while BJ’s also offers competitive prices. Both Costco and BJ’s offer additional perks to their members who purchase gas. For example, Costco offers a 4% cashback reward on gas purchases for Executive Members, while BJ’s offers a similar program called BJ’s Perks Rewards.

Conclusion

When it comes to buying gas at warehouse clubs, both Costco and BJ’s offer competitive prices.

However, Costco has an advantage when it comes to gas quality. Their Top Tier gas is of higher quality than BJ’s gas.

Ultimately, the best option for you will depend on your location, credit card affiliations, and car’s gas requirements.

Learn More

  • Is Costco Gas Better Than Arco?
  • Why Is Costco Gas So Popular?
  • Where Does Costco Get Their Gas?
  • Does Costco Sell Propane?
Is Costco Gas Better Than BJ's? [A Comparative Analysis] - (2024)

FAQs

What is better, Costco or BJ? ›

A basic annual Costco membership costs $60 and includes similar benefits to BJ's. Costco's upgraded executive membership is $120 annually and offers cash-back perks like BJ's. A major difference between the two warehouses is that BJ's accepts manufacturer's coupons, and Costco does not.

Is BJS worth it for gas? ›

According to Motorbiscuit, BJ's gas prices tend to be 10 cents lower than the national average which should be middling at best. In comparison, Costco gas prices are 19.8 cents cheaper than other brands which are generally the cheapest compared to other brands.

What is the market share of BJ's vs Costco? ›

Sales and market share

Market share? As of August 2022, Costco holds the largest share of the wholesale club market, 55.5%. Sam's followed that, 36.2%, and BJ's came in far behind, 8.3%, according to the career data site Zippia.

Are Costco and BJ's owned by the same company? ›

Costco stores are owned and run by Costco Corporation, which is traded on the NASDAQ as symbol COST. BJ's stores are similarly owned by BJ's Corporation and is traded on the NYSE under symbol BJ. So, neither companies are owned by another big box chain.

Does Costco price match BJ? ›

Costco does not price match with other sellers. Costco does not price match Costco warehouse prices for Costco.com purchases.

Who is the biggest competitor to Costco? ›

Walmart. Walmart is one of Costco's leading competitors and alternatives. Founded in 1962, Walmart is a multinational retail corporation that operates a chain of hypermarkets, discount department stores, and grocery stores. With over 10,500 stores worldwide, Walmart is a significant player in the retail industry.

Does BJs sell Top Tier gasoline? ›

Oddly enough I've seen the tanker pull out of Costco and head over to BJ's. Usually gas stations have a sticker on the pump saying it's Top Tier.

Does bj's gas have detergents? ›

BJ'S gasoline contains all detergent additives required by EPA guidelines.

How to save on gas at BJs? ›

Stack your savings over multiple trips.

BJ's Fuel Saver items can be purchased online & in-club. Excludes delivery.bjs.com. *For each eligible fuel saver item purchased at BJ's, save 10¢/gal. on your next BJ's Gas® fuel purchase ($99.00 or 40 gal.

What does Costco do better than its competitors? ›

Costco makes some of its profits from its merchandise, but the bulk of its profits come from membership dues. Only members can shop at Costco. The membership business model allows Costco to undersell the competition by offering products in bulk at lower prices to ensure customer loyalty.

Where does Costco rank? ›

As of 2021, Costco is the third-largest retailer in the world and is the world's largest retailer of choice and prime beef, organic foods, rotisserie chicken, and wine as of 2016. Costco is ranked #11 on the Fortune 500 rankings of the largest United States corporations by total revenue.

Which came first Costco or BJ's? ›

Costco was founded in 1976, while BJ's emerged years later in 1984, but both have since been compared to one another over time.

Where does BJ's get their meat from in the USA? ›

Wellsley Farms (BJ's Wholesale Club)

Is Kirkland brand Costco or BJ's? ›

Costco's private brand, Kirkland Signature, tends to be high quality at a great price. You can trust the name and you'll be happy.

Who manufactures Wellsley Farms? ›

Is Wellsley Farms a BJ's Wholesale Club Brand? Yes, Wellsley Farms is a BJ's Wholesale Club privately-owned brand name label that incorporates a full selection of quality BJs dairy products, BJs produce, BJs snacks, BJs juices, BJs desserts, and fresh heat-and-eat meals for your family.

Who has the best prices, Sam's Club, BJ's or Costco? ›

An AARP study from October 2023 agreed: Sam's Club lets shoppers save the most when buying in bulk, compared to Costco and BJ's. The downside: Sam's doesn't have the premium brands Costco often carries, they wrote.

Is Costco cheaper than most stores? ›

Costco is known as a low-price leader, but as the big-box and warehouse store landscape becomes more and more competitive, it's getting harder to find unbeatable deals. Despite this, Costco still has some major purchasing power, which helps it keep costs way low.

Is BJs or Costco better to work for? ›

BJ's Wholesale Club is most highly rated for Work/life balance and Costco Wholesale is most highly rated for Compensation and benefits.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5351

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Birthday: 2001-08-13

Address: 96487 Kris Cliff, Teresiafurt, WI 95201

Phone: +9418513585781

Job: Senior Designer

Hobby: Calligraphy, Rowing, Vacation, Geocaching, Web surfing, Electronics, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Benton Quitzon, I am a comfortable, charming, thankful, happy, adventurous, handsome, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.